Follow Up on Mortgage Insurer Stocks As Junk Bonds

I've done some further reading on the mortgage insurance situation and it is interesting enough to merit a second post.  The below article is a good overview of the competing interests trying to stake claims in the mortgage insurance arena after 3 of the main players were shut down by regulators in the last few years (one of them, PMI).

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-08-22/arizona-regulator-sues-nmi-showing-watchdog-influence-mortgages.html

Let me give you what I believe are the most salient points:

• The Arizona Department of Insurance, acting as the receiver of the defunct PMI, has sued upstart would-be mortgage insurer NMI Holdings from improperly appropriating PMI assets. The suit could hinder NMI from selling mortgage insurance;

My thought:  former PMI employees are anxious to get back in the business

• Private mortgage insurers, which have lost more than $18 billion since mid-2007, wrote $40.1 billion of coverage last quarter, or almost 10 percent of the $405 billion of new loans.

My thought:  I'm absolutely astounded that the industry wrote more coverage last quarter than the amount of losses suffered during the housing crash

• MGIC’s preliminary ratio of risk relative to capital breached the level some regulators require to write new policies as of June 30, the insurer said Aug. 2.

My thoughts:  MGIC should probably be shut down but is being allowed to continue to operate

• Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS), JPMorgan Chase & Co (JPM), private-equity firm Pine Brook and reinsurer PartnerRe Ltd. are among backers of the industry’s other startup, Essent Guaranty Inc. The Radnor, Pennsylvania-based firm raised $600 million in 2009 and 2010 and began writing policies last year, providing 5.3 percent of coverage in the first half of this year.

My thoughts:  Goldman and JP Morgan see an opportunity in mortgage insurance.  The management team at Essent looks like it's been poached from other major mortgage insurers. 

One more thought, not from the article.  There was significant insider buying of shares in August of this year.  See http://seekingalpha.com/article/789171-why-i-bought-mgic-investment-corp-for-a-trade.
 
This is starting to look even more interesting.  I will continue to follow this industry.